What’s your point of view? Should we be closed to spiritual gifts because some abuse them?
Abusus Non Tollit Usum is a Latin phrase—“Abuse does not take away use.”
In other words, the misuse of something is not an argument against it’s proper use. Stay with me …
See ‘Go Further’ resources at the bottom of this post.
An obvious fallacy
Fire can burn and destroy. It also cooks and brings warmth.
- Some case of X did something wrong.
- Therefore, all X’s are bad.
- We should get rid of X’s.
Fire is good when properly understood and applied.
To feminists, it tends to look like this:
- Some men are bad.
- Certainly, all men are evil.
- We should get rid of men. Or at least force men to stop being men.
This kind of thinking is a fallacy. It’s an argument from “one” or “some” to a conclusion about “all.”
Anything can be distorted
Any belief or point of view can be distorted.
Doctrine or faith practice can be distorted and misused as well. People get hurt.
The Bible and Christianity have been grossly misused to justify atrocious evils throughout history. Of course it’s maddening.
Sometimes, when you have spent a long time rejecting the gifts of the Spirit and come to believe in them, you almost feel as if you are being born again. — Jack Deere,
But Biblical faith has also been expressed in lifting the poor, empowering women and children, shaping economic and public policy to elevate societies, sparking philanthropic initiatives, creating horizons of hope, and much more.
And yet the fallacy can remain …
- Some expressions of biblical faith are bad.
- Therefore, all expressions of biblical faith are bad.
- We should get rid of biblical faith. Or at least restrict it’s expression.
Distortion and abuse are not limited to Christianity or the Bible. It’s everywhere and in everything.
What about the misuse of spiritual gifts (charismata)?
You can choose almost any truth, doctrine, or faith practice from the Bible and find some way that it has been distorted, abused, and improperly applied.
Somewhere. By someone.
Consider spiritual gifts. They are given for the common good of the assembly of believers, the church (1 Corinthians 12:7).
They were only for the early Christ-followers, right? (We’ll explore the validity and use of spiritual gifts for today on this site as content is added.)
But what about the issue of misusing spiritual gifts … what do we do with that?
Well, the fallacy thinking would say:
- Some misuse spiritual gifts.
- Therefore, all expressions of spiritual gifts are a misuse.
- So, spiritual gifts should not be used by today’s Christ-followers.
Again: Abusus Non Tollit Usum —“Abuse does not take away use.”
Paul and spiritual gifts — Abusus Non Tollit Usum
This is in large part why Paul wrote his first letter to the Corinthian church.
That in every way you were enriched in him in all speech and all knowledge—even as the testimony about Christ was confirmed among you—so that you are not lacking in any gift, as you wait for the revealing of our Lord Jesus Christ (1 Corinthians 1:5-7 ESV).
Paul was grateful that the Corinthian believers were not lacking in spiritual gifts. He said they were not to lack in any gift as they waited for (or until) the revelation of Christ when he comes again. See also 1 Corinthians 13:9-12.
The Word of God still speaks to us today. What Paul wrote to the Corinthian believers is for all believers for all time—just as every other letter and book in the New Testament is timeless for New Covenant believers.
Now concerning spiritual gifts, brothers, I do not want you to be uninformed (1 Corinthians 12:1 ESV).
Paul did not write to the Corinthian Christ-followers and tell them that spiritual gifts had ceased. He wrote to correct the misuse and misapplication of spiritual gifts.
Abusus Non Tollit Usum.
See Paul’s teaching on spiritual gifts in 1 Corinthians 12-14. Love as a prime value and motivator is given central place in these chapters (see chapter 13).
Clearly, the mature use of spiritual gifts is at the top of Paul’s concerns for communities of faith—local churches.
Heavenly Father, I thank you that you’ve sent the Holy Spirit to teach us and bring us into all truth. I want to experience full-spectrum Christian faith. I praise you that the very anointing of Christ teaches me as I search the Scriptures. Continue to bring me into next-level Christ-following. I’m grateful. Amen.
What’s your point of view? Should today’s Christ-followers exercise spiritual gifts?